Who beats who?

Between Frankie Edgar, Gilbert Melendez and Eddie Alvarez, who wins each match up?

Frankie Edgar, Gilbert Melendez and Eddie Alvarez. In that order.

Frankie, BJ, Eddie, Maynard, KenFlo, Gil

Frankie, BJ, Maynard, KenFlo, Gil and Eddie.

freakzilla316ftw wrote:

Frankie, BJ, Maynard, KenFlo, Gil and Eddie.

Hehe and woah, Eddie that low

Yep, who has Alvarez beat? He lost to Aoki and Melendez beat Aoki.

Not really how you should judge fighters, I mean Gil has loses to Thompson and Ishida, and he beat Crusher, Hansen, JZ, Kikuno, then destroyed Neer and Huerta like no one else has.

Melendez has the bigger win on his resume and beat the guy Alvarez lost too. So for now Melendez is ranked higher and there is nothing to show that Alvarez is better.

Edgar-Gil: Edgar
Alvarez-Gil: Alvarez
Alvarez-Edgar: toss up for me but I lean Eddie

bobbitt15 wrote:

Edgar-Gil: Edgar
Alvarez-Gil: Alvarez
Alvarez-Edgar: toss up for me but I lean Eddie

this!!! what Eddie did to Huerta last night was sick, i'm a believer

It's Huerta not BJ Penn.

freakzilla316ftw wrote:

It's Huerta not BJ Penn.

when was the last time Huerta was dominated like that? don't say Maynard cuz he held his own in that fight, he got wrecked by Eddie

I think Eddie beats Gil and Eddie vs Frankie would be a toss up to me right now.

OU wrote:

I think Eddie beats Gil and Eddie vs Frankie would be a toss up to me right now.

i knew you'd have my back you sooner fuck!

killerofchicken wrote:

OU wrote:

I think Eddie beats Gil and Eddie vs Frankie would be a toss up to me right now.

i knew you'd have my back you sooner fuck!

Sooner fuck? Is that what you mom is saying I did to her?

OU wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

OU wrote:

I think Eddie beats Gil and Eddie vs Frankie would be a toss up to me right now.

i knew you'd have my back you sooner fuck!

Sooner fuck? Is that what you mom is saying I did to her?

oh please, with your little pecker you'd be lucky to please a midget!

this is the first event i DVR'ed and it was in HD!!! O YEA!

Maynard just beats everybody without dominating. Huerta lost his last fight to Pat Curran. Alvarez lost to Aoki who got dominated by Gilbert. Dominating a 3rd rate organization and beating no top 20 talent doesn't put you in the top 5.

killerofchicken wrote:

OU wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

OU wrote:

I think Eddie beats Gil and Eddie vs Frankie would be a toss up to me right now.

i knew you'd have my back you sooner fuck!

Sooner fuck? Is that what you mom is saying I did to her?

oh please, with your little pecker you'd be lucky to please a midget!

Please, my dick is big enough to play Linebacker for OU

freakzilla316ftw wrote:

Maynard just beats everybody without dominating. Huerta lost his last fight to Pat Curran. Alvarez lost to Aoki who got dominated by Gilbert. Dominating a 3rd rate organization and beating no top 20 talent doesn't put you in the top 5.

matchups make fights though, i'm just saying that eddie looked unstoppable and don't forget, eddie lost to aoki 2 years ago! his BJJ is so much better today

That Gil vs Eddie matchup really needs to happen.

OU wrote:

That Gil vs Eddie matchup really needs to happen.

they called out Coker and Gill last night once again, Bellator CEO Bjorn Rebney said they'd do it in san jose under the strikeforce banner just to make it happen!

http://www.sherdog.com/news/news/Alvarez-Strikeforces-Coker-Trying-to-Protect-Melendez-27690


“There aren’t promotional issues,” Rebney said. “There aren’t any barriers to entry. There aren’t any hurdles.”
:Rebney

killerofchicken wrote:

OU wrote:

That Gil vs Eddie matchup really needs to happen.

they called out Coker and Gill last night once again, Bellator CEO Bjorn Rebney said they'd do it in san jose under the strikeforce banner just to make it happen!

I hope they make it 5 rounds, even if neither title is on the line.

OU wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

OU wrote:

That Gil vs Eddie matchup really needs to happen.

they called out Coker and Gill last night once again, Bellator CEO Bjorn Rebney said they'd do it in san jose under the strikeforce banner just to make it happen!

I hope they make it 5 rounds, even if neither title is on the line.

As much as i'd like that, i cant see it happening... if at all the fight happens