Best QB in the NFL(2012 version)

Things have changed a little bit. Probably can't consider Peyton to be the best in the game today, but I'll still put him on the list. Try not to be a homer. I'm going to leave off some of the very good QBs that I don't think anyone can honestly say is the best right now.

Brady.

josh200612 wrote:

Brady.

As much as I hate him you may be right. But I kind of think Aaron is still the most talented QB right now. Tough call.

I said fuck it and voted Rodgers. But it's a tough call.

Whaaaaaat? Where the hell is smith?

Farmer1906 wrote:

Whaaaaaat? Where the hell is smith?

LOL

Tom Brady is the best for career, but Rodgers is better today.

Have to roll Brady over Rodgers even. Dude has had a constantly changing recieving core as opposed to the great core Rodgers inherited in GB(Driver, Jennings, Finley, and Nelson). It seems like every year Brady has a new rockstar reciever on the team other than Welker.

I still think most years in their career Peyton>Tom.

Big Ben in my opinion.

OU wrote:

I still think most years in their career Peyton>Tom.

Most years absolutely. We saw what happened in contrast to their teams when they went down for a season. 11-5 with Matt Cassel vs 2-14 with Curtis Painter/Dan Orlovski/Kerry Collins really says it all.

Before Manning got hurt he would have been number 1 for me hands down.

timthebim wrote:

Big Ben in my opinion.

wow, really? He is getting better but I still don't know if he is top 5 for me.

Ludo wrote:

OU wrote:

I still think most years in their career Peyton>Tom.

Most years absolutely. We saw what happened in contrast to their teams when they went down for a season. 11-5 with Matt Cassel vs 2-14 with Curtis Painter/Dan Orlovski/Kerry Collins really says it all.

To be fair I think Cassel is decent and his team suffered alot of injuries last season.

I say Rogers. No one has a better or more consistent combination of efficiently moving the ball, accuracy, down field throws, out of pocket passing, scrambling and rushing, red zone decision making and making his players around him better. He might not be the best at any of them, but cumulatively, he is the best.

OU wrote:

I still think most years in their career Peyton>Tom.

LOL!