Which team wins this match-up?

All players at their peaks.

Team A-

C - Dikembe Mutumbo
PF- Dennis Rodman
SF- Scottie Pippen
SG- Reggie Miller
PG- Gary Payton

Team B-

C - Shaquille O'neal
PF- Carmelo Anthony
SF- Tracy McGrady
SG- Kobe Bryant
PG- Allen Iverson

Team B. Shaq in his prime plus the crazy scoring of Kobe and AI.

OU wrote:

Team B. Shaq in his prime plus the crazy scoring of Kobe and AI.

Can they co-exist? there's only 1 ball.

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

Team B. Shaq in his prime plus the crazy scoring of Kobe and AI.

Can they co-exist? there's only 1 ball.

For 1 game? Sure they can. AI wants to win, he was able to share enough with Melo. They had a season where both finished in the top 5 in the league in scoring.

OU wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

Team B. Shaq in his prime plus the crazy scoring of Kobe and AI.

Can they co-exist? there's only 1 ball.

For 1 game? Sure they can. AI wants to win, he was able to share enough with Melo. They had a season where both finished in the top 5 in the league in scoring.

That wasn't AI's peak though. In 2001 he would've never shared it. I meant this to be in a 7 game series. My bad.

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

Team B. Shaq in his prime plus the crazy scoring of Kobe and AI.

Can they co-exist? there's only 1 ball.

For 1 game? Sure they can. AI wants to win, he was able to share enough with Melo. They had a season where both finished in the top 5 in the league in scoring.

That wasn't AI's peak though. In 2001 he would've never shared it. I meant this to be in a 7 game series. My bad.

He never had anyone to share it with. I'm sure AI would have killed to have anyone with even the slightest ability to score the year he made it to the NBA finals all by his damn self. Even in a 7 games series, AI would share with another elite scorer. He just never played with one until late in his career.

Team B and it isnt even close.

You guys actually think Carmelo, McGrady, AI and Kobe would share the ball?

freakzilla wrote:

You guys actually think Carmelo, McGrady, AI and Kobe would share the ball?

So I'm guessing that you arguing for team A? Yes, those guys would share the ball with other elite players.

Team B would find a way to score, with good or bad sharing, Shaq cleans up down low. Team B wins 4-2.

Besides Reggie all other 4 guys on team A are all-time greats on D.

OU wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

You guys actually think Carmelo, McGrady, AI and Kobe would share the ball?

So I'm guessing that you arguing for team A? Yes, those guys would share the ball with other elite players.

If Team A had Olajuwon or Duncan instead of Mutumbo or Rodman I would say them for sure but right now I'm undecided.

LOL come on Freak, you obviously had an answer set in your mind when you asked the question and you were looking/hoping to have everyone agree. You asked, we gave our best answers. I don't think team A stands much of a chance in a 7 game series.

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

You guys actually think Carmelo, McGrady, AI and Kobe would share the ball?

So I'm guessing that you arguing for team A? Yes, those guys would share the ball with other elite players.

If Team A had Olajuwon or Duncan instead of Mutumbo or Rodman I would say them for sure but right now I'm undecided.

Looks like you went defense vs offense. Take away prime Shaq and you get a better game.

OU wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

You guys actually think Carmelo, McGrady, AI and Kobe would share the ball?

So I'm guessing that you arguing for team A? Yes, those guys would share the ball with other elite players.

If Team A had Olajuwon or Duncan instead of Mutumbo or Rodman I would say them for sure but right now I'm undecided.

Looks like you went defense vs offense. Take away prime Shaq and you get a better game.

Yeah I went D vs O. Wanted to see everyone's thoughts on whether team B would co-exist or not. I might have left team A short of an inside presence on O though.

Team A-

C - Dwight Howard
PF- Karl Malone
SF- Scottie Pippen
SG- Reggie Miller
PG- Chris Paul

Team B-

C - Shaquille O'neal
PF- Carmelo Anthony
SF- Tracy McGrady
SG- Kobe Bryant
PG- Allen Iverson

better game

B

Team bwith ease realky

referring to the OP..i take Team A. They are much superior defensivley, everybody on Team A is a team player, and they can also score.

Melo and McGrady havent got shit on Worm and Pip.

Also Team A will get most rebounds.

Agree. B easily.

KingsOwn19 wrote:

referring to the OP..i take Team A. They are much superior defensivley, everybody on Team A is a team player, and they can also score.

Melo and McGrady havent got shit on Worm and Pip.

Yeah but we are talking a prime Shaq. That just changes everything. Mutumbo might as well be Anthony Davis because he isn't going to slow prime Shaq down even for a second. Not only that but prime Kobe would be the best player on the court. It wouldn't even be a competitive series.

Prime Shaq is better than prime Kobe.

freakzilla wrote:

Prime Shaq is better than prime Kobe.

Well if you think that, then how can team B stand a chance? Mutumbo would get rag dolled either way. Shaq would dominate and no one on team A could do a damn thing about it.