Chuck Liddell?

Overrated, he lost to Page in Pride while he was at his peak, Shogun would have killed him

Based on who beats who-

1. Mauricio Rua
2. Wanderlei Silva
3. Rampage Jackson

I could also see Lyoto Machida ahead of him and when it's all said and done Jon Jones could end up being the GOAT.

Question, who wins Prime Chuck Liddell or Prime Frank Shamrock?

Prime Chuck.

Jamal wrote:

Based on who beats who-

1. Mauricio Rua
2. Wanderlei Silva
3. Rampage Jackson

I could also see Lyoto Machida ahead of him and when it's all said and done Jon Jones could end up being the GOAT.

Question, who wins Prime Chuck Liddell or Prime Frank Shamrock?

I thnk Frank would get his world rocked...

you said (LA) that he lost to one of the top 3 guys so thought thats what your list was

Guy Mezger was able to knock Chuck around he just couldnt keep up the pace or continue to eat the blows i think Frank could have

It would be a good fight but I would take Chuck.

Birdofthad wrote:

Guy Mezger was able to knock Chuck around he just couldnt keep up the pace or continue to eat the blows i think Frank could have

i think frank would have been tko'd, and I dont think he could take chuck down and in my opinion the only way frank beats chuck is on the mat

chuck hits way too hard for frank to take it IMO

Birdofthad wrote:

you said (LA) that he lost to one of the top 3 guys so thought thats what your list was

You said he probably wasn't even the best in his division at the time.

I said that guy was top 3 also, and he beat him.

Wandy is the guy.

Frank woulda beat the piss out of Chuck.

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Frank woulda beat the piss out of Chuck.

Doubt it.

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Frank woulda beat the piss out of Chuck.

really? HOW? i can't see frank taking chuck down, no way he beats him standing!!! chuck has way too much power

timthebim wrote:

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Frank woulda beat the piss out of Chuck.

Doubt it.

Yup

remember Randys slam on Chuck? Just saying Frank noticed things like against Zinoviev e before fight) noticed Zinovievs sprawl base was horrible so when he shot instead of going to the mat he lifted Zinoviev and demped him on his head, Frak would have found a way to beat Chuck IMO , cause in his prime thats what he always seemed to do

Isee what you were saying LA my bad misread or misinterpreted

Frank's the biggest "what if" guy in MMA history though.

LA wrote:

Frank's the biggest "what if" guy in MMA history though.

yeah, kinda agree with you on that one... it could have been him were talking about instead of chuck at this time, if you know what i mean

Frank was a better striker than Chuck, sorry to tell ya.

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Frank was a better striker than Chuck, sorry to tell ya.

Didnt have no where near the power Chuck had though.

LA wrote:

Frank's the biggest "what if" guy in MMA history though.

Why? Cause he dominated when u werent watching? He owned that era like chuck never did.

Birdofthad wrote:

LA wrote:

Frank's the biggest "what if" guy in MMA history though.

Why? Cause he dominated when u werent watching? He owned that era like chuck never did.

Not so sure Bird. There was a time not to long ago where Chuck dominated the division and was the most popular fighter in the world.

Ya and there was this thing called pride , frank won a king of pancreas title then came to ufc and put together one of the most dominant runs ever seen

Add in frank was really a 195 pounder and it's impressive this conversation is happening. Disagree? His original middleweight belt now light heavy was 200 and under

Birdofthad wrote:

Ya and there was this thing called pride , frank won a king of pancreas title then came to ufc and put together one of the most dominant runs ever seen

There was pride but Chuck could only beat who he was allowed to fight.

Which doesn't make you the best ever IMO. I just think frank wins and he doesn't have to get to the ground technical strikers always gave chuck problems, like mezger, I think frank could have won and would have leg kicked a lot and moved