Worse decision

Which one was worse and why?

Edgar vs Penn to me was worse.

errr yeah horrible decision,
first rd- back and forth but zombie almost finishes him twice
2nd rd- garcia looks better rocks zombie but 2 failed td attempts and zombie took him down and had his back.
3rd rd- zombie hurts garcia again pretty sloppy but zombie again dictates and controls the cage.


RD1 10-9 zombie (could be 10-8 )
rd 2- 10-10
rd 3 10-9 zombie

I would have to Garcia vs Jung, considering Zombie didn't even lose a round during that fight.

Penn-Edgar

who gives a fuck about two middle of the pack FW's in comp to a great champ having his belt jacked?

KingsOwn19 wrote:

Penn-Edgar

who gives a fuck about two middle of the pack FW's in comp to a great champ having his belt jacked?

I think you're missing the point.

No one will dispute which fight was bigger or more important. The decision is what's being discussed and the Zombie-Gracie fight was very one sided and judged wrongly. The Edgar-Penn fight was controversial because it could have gone either way. There are arguments to be made both sides.

yeah penn edgar was definetly more costly to the looser but this fight IMO was more lopsided

Jung vs Garcia

Jun at best won or should have done enough to get 10-10 in the rounds he did win convincingly (3rd for me, 2nd was close)

both were good close fights, I think Jung had seperatedhimself more though

I personally did not catch this fight with Garcia but 50-45 and 49-46 scores for Penn and Edgar show that the fight was saw through flawed eyes and considering the implications and the fact Edgar only won 2 rounds AT BEST yet one judge had him winning five and another four, which is the difference no matter what way the 48-47 judge went, Penn-Edgar wins out here.

Jung won all three rounds pretty handily, he was walking Garcia down in every round(aggressiveness), he stuffed all Garcia's takedowns (octagon control), he landed more shots, at one point in the second I believe he landed 10 punches in a row while Garcia was failing at covering up. He also took Garcia's back and took him down and knocked him down with punches at one point. I had it 30-27 for Jung, and I had money on Garcia to win. Jung got robbed and it wasn't even close.

Obviously the worst decision was the robbery in the title fight.

Both fights were close, but I suppose in terms of what was just a more wrong decision I'll go with Penn again, because Garcia hurt Jung in every round, and Penn had an owie on his cheek after the fight and was never in danger once.