Feedback, arguing and general BS'ing about my top ten list.

Sorry I was dealing with LA claiming the loss of Jake Shields and Gegard Mousasi would destroy Strikeforce. Ya, I know...I know....


Anyway, a lot of it is opinion, half of what you said I admitted was missed, like no Silva at LHW.

No Maia? I swore I had him in there, fine, bump Melvin and stick him where ever you wish, or remove his clone Jacare and put him in there.

I addressed the Sherk thing. I cannot believe one loss in a fight he simply brought the wrong game plan to has done so much damage to the former champion's rep. A fight before that he out boxed Tyson Griffin. That fight like never ever happened to everyone. Sean Sherk could still beat anyone not named BJ, and a fight where he didn't use his wrestling at all and just converted into a boxer shouldn't change that.

Kawajiri is a bad ass mother fucker and I have him where a lot of other sites do, so whatever.

BJ Penn's ranking clearly has more to do with his talent than his in weight fights. Do you think Josh Koscheck, Jon Fitch or Thiago Alves could beat him? Do you really?

The Barnett thing for you sounds like it has more to do with anger at Affliction's collapse than anything else. No one in the UFC would stand a chance against him now that Mirko is shot, apart from maybe Nog, imo. I am sure you'll swoon on and on about Mir or Lesnar, but I simply disagree. Barnett would beat all, including Lesnars, faces in.

If AA has the worst chin in MMA for those KO's how bad is Mir and Randy's then? He is the best active striker in the HW division these days, with a nod to JDS, and that Fedor overhand right, and a four punch combo from Rogers, Lesnar, Carwin or anyone that size would KO nearly anyone. Not sold on this horrible chin business in this weight class with those guys.

I never said just those two alone, I named Fedor and Nick as other losses orginally

Also don't bother OG, let this thread die, horrible rankings

Yes, but you said all it would take is two of the four fighters to spell real trouble right? Don't back peddle now son.