New P4P lists!

Ali_1748 wrote:

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

#1 Anderson Silva
#2 GSP
#3 BJ Penn
#4 Lyoto Machida
#5 Gegard Mousasi

Honorable mentions Shogun,Faber,Sheilds

Damn Ali, even Andrew has Fedor in the top-5...

I don't like putting heavyweights in my p4p lists it ruins the whole concept of p4p. It's not that I don't rate Fedor I think he's a fantastic mixed martial artist.

If that's what spins your merry-go-round, works for me. Just wanted to make sure you weren't dissin Fedor...

lol of course I am not dissing Fedor.

Ali_1748 wrote:

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

#1 Anderson Silva
#2 GSP
#3 BJ Penn
#4 Lyoto Machida
#5 Gegard Mousasi

Honorable mentions Shogun,Faber,Sheilds

Damn Ali, even Andrew has Fedor in the top-5...

I don't like putting heavyweights in my p4p lists it ruins the whole concept of p4p. It's not that I don't rate Fedor I think he's a fantastic mixed martial artist.

Why Faber Above MTB?

Jose Aldo is about to be on everyone's list very soon.

If you dont have Fedor in ur top 3 then GTFO!

oggy420 wrote:

If you dont have Fedor in ur top 3 then GTFO!

co-sign

Ninja\Rua/Fan wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

#1 Anderson Silva
#2 GSP
#3 BJ Penn
#4 Lyoto Machida
#5 Gegard Mousasi

Honorable mentions Shogun,Faber,Sheilds

Damn Ali, even Andrew has Fedor in the top-5...

I don't like putting heavyweights in my p4p lists it ruins the whole concept of p4p. It's not that I don't rate Fedor I think he's a fantastic mixed martial artist.

Why Faber Above MTB?

I think Faber is a better all round fighter. Almost submitted him in the rematch with injured hands.

oggy420 wrote:

If you dont have Fedor in ur top 3 then GTFO!

No

oggy that gif rocks

My P4P List:

1. Fedor Emelianenko
:::Wins over Big Nog(2), Cro-Cop, Coleman, Arlovski, Sylvia, Rogers.
2. Anderson Silva
:::Hasn't lost in 3 years and has won most of his matches in dominant fashion.
3. George St. Pierre
:::Lost only once in the past 5 years and went on to avenge that loss.
4. BJ Penn
:::Noone can touch him the lightweight division, his record would be nearly unblemished if it wasn't for him moving back and forth between weight divisions.
5. Gegard Mousasi
:::One of the fastest rising starts in all of MMA, with already a boat load of fighting experience. His cool and calm demeanor resembles that of the Last Emperor, which whom he often trains with.
6. Lyoto Machida
:::Practically invincible before his bout with Shogun Rua. Look for him to put away any doubt about who's the best in the Light Heavyweight division in May.
7. Jose Aldo
:::Dismantled Mike Thomas Brown. Enough said.
8. Brian Bowles
:::Continues to add to a short but impressive resume after defeating the great Miguel Torres.
9. Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira
:::That's right. Big Nog belongs on this list because of his gaudy 32-5-1 career record. Listen to whom he lost to. Fedor(2), Barnett, Henderson, and Mir. Noone else has a resume of his caliber except for Fedor. And I refuse to hold that Mir loss against him because we have since learned that he was fighting an injury during that fight. The real Nog was on display in his last match against Couture. If there is an interim match for the heavyweight title because of Lesnar's illness, Nogueira should be in line for a title shot, probably against Carwin.
10. Rashad Evans
Before his loss to Machida, Evans was undefeated with victories over Bisping, Liddell, and Forrest Griffin. After he beats Thiago Silva, he'll race back up everyone's board once more.