MMA RANKINGS - CHAPTER 3...

hwy

1)Cain
2)JDS
3)Big Foot
4)Reem
5)Brock
6)Werdum
7)carwin
8)Mir
9)Barnett
10)Konrad

lhwy
1)Bones
2)Shogun
3)Evans
4)Page
5)Hendo
6)Machida
7)Forrest
8)Phil Davis
9)Gegard
10)Cavalcante

mw
1)Silva
2)Jacare
3)Belfort
4)Lombard
5)Stann
6)Chael
7)Bisping
8)Okami
9)Munoz
10)Shlemenko

ww
1)GSP
2)Fitch
3)Jake
4)Diaz
5)Condit
6)Penn
7)Kos
8)Askren
9)Hendricks
10)Woodley

lw
1)Edgar
2)maynard
3)Gil
4)Bendo
5)Eddie
6)Clay
7)Aoki
8)Guillard
9)Jim Miller
10)Pettis

fw
1)Aldo
2)Mendes
3)Warren
4)Curran
5)Hioki
6)Flo
7)Friere
8)Sandro
9)Nunes
10)Griffin

bw
1)Cruz
2)Faber
3)Bowles
4)benavidez
5)Johnson
6)Makovsky
7)Jorgenson
8)torres
9)Barao
10)Pickett

I'll get on this soon since it looks like we got some decent participation.

1. Anderson Silva
2. GSP
3. Jose Aldo
4. Jon Jones
5. Frankie Edgar
6. Jon Fitch
7. Dominick Cruz
8. Jake Shields
9. Rashad Evans
10. Gilbert Melendez

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Junior Dos Santos

freakzilla wrote:

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Jake Shields

No change for me
1. GSP
2. Anderson
3. Aldo
4. Jones
5. Edgar
6. Maynard
7. Cruz
8. Cain
9. Fitch
10. JDS

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Jake Shields

Maynard is at least as good as Edgar. You have a hate for all heavyweights in P4P rankings. Both GSP and Jones would beat Anderson.

freakzilla wrote:

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Jake Shields

Maynard is at least as good as Edgar. You have a hate for all heavyweights in P4P rankings. Both GSP and Jones would beat Anderson.

Actually I am not entirely against putting HW's in there, I just don't think Cain's cracked the top ten yet.

freakzilla wrote:

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Jake Shields

Maynard is at least as good as Edgar. You have a hate for all heavyweights in P4P rankings. Both GSP and Jones would beat Anderson.

Edgar is a 145er fighting ag 155. These are p4p, I would have Frankie over Gray in p4p but not in the LW rankings. Same goes for BJ and Fitch. I think Fitch is the better WW but BJ is the better p4p fighter. HWs are at a big disadvantage since generally they aren't as well rounded/overall skilled as the smaller fighters.

1.Anderson
2.GSP
3.Jose Aldo
4.Jones
5.Shogun
6.Fitch
7.BJ
8.Nick Diaz
9.Cruz
10.JDS

1.GSP
2.Spider
3.Aldo
4.Frankie
5.Cruz
6.Joe Benavidez
7.BJ
8.Fitch
9.Jones
10.Nick Diaz

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Jake Shields

Maynard is at least as good as Edgar. You have a hate for all heavyweights in P4P rankings. Both GSP and Jones would beat Anderson.

Actually I am not entirely against putting HW's in there, I just don't think Cain's cracked the top ten yet.

You have none in your MMA or Boxing p4p top 10.

freakzilla wrote:

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

Ali wrote:

freakzilla wrote:

01. Georges St. Pierre
02. Jon Jones
03. Anderson Silva
04. Jose Aldo
05. Cain Velasquez
06. Frankie Edgar
07. Gray Maynard
08. Mauricio Rua
09. Rashad Evans
10. Jake Shields

Maynard is at least as good as Edgar. You have a hate for all heavyweights in P4P rankings. Both GSP and Jones would beat Anderson.

Actually I am not entirely against putting HW's in there, I just don't think Cain's cracked the top ten yet.

You have none in your MMA or Boxing p4p top 10.

That's because none are worthy. However IF Cain impresses against Cigano I'd be happy to place him in there.

Cain and Wlad are easily worthy.

1 Silva
2 GSP
3 Aldo
4 Cruz
5 Jones
6 Rua
7 Maynard
8 Velasquez
9 Edgar
10 Penn

freakzilla wrote:

Cain and Wlad are easily worthy.

Wladimir Klitschko is one of the worst HW champions boxing has ever had.

MMAEYES wrote:

MW
1.Silva
2.Belfort
3.Sonnen
4.Jacare
5.Okami
6.Maia
7.Bisping
8.Munoz
9.Lombard
10.Miller

Hey MMAEYES, can you clarify what Miller you are ranking here, Dan and Jason are generally pretty close on the scale. Thanks.

OU wrote:

only a couple adjustments that came to mind.

Is that your,,, final answer?

lock it in.

Props go out to "Mr. Excel" himself

Did I really fucking leave Condit off my rankings? Damn, what an overlook.

OU wrote:

Did I really fucking leave Condit off my rankings? Damn, what an overlook.

No he is on there. But the table doesn't show me as voting for him?

I was gonna say what an idiot.

It has me voting for Alves but not Condit, which is wrong.

I may have voted for Alves.