Who won? BJ Penn or Jon Fitch (Vote)

?

I had it a draw.

Draw

KingsOwn19 wrote:

I had it a draw.

That's fair enough. I had Fitch but I won't argue too much against a draw. No way Penn won though.

Hey! What are you guys doing in here? Oh well I'll cya later now!

For the guys that voted draw is it because you had the 2nd round as 10-10 or is it because you gave the 3rd to Fitch 10-8?

Round 1 was Penn's 10-9
Round 3 was Fitch's 10-9 or 10-8
Round 2 could have gone either way 10-9 or even a 10-10.

It could have been 29-28 Penn, 29-27 Fitch, or anywhere in between.

29-28 Penn in my book. BJ won the 1st and 2nd rounds 10-9 and Fitch won the the 3rd 10-9 which is why I think BJ won. If we could judge total fight yes Fitch won but we judge round by round and I felt BJ won the 1st 2 and Fitch the 3rd.

I had it Fitch, but I understood the draw too. So I am not disappointed.

lol bbc had the best comment by far.

josh200612 wrote:

lol bbc had the best comment by far.

Yeah he did.

This fight clearly belonged to Fitch. The second was obviously his, and the third was an obvious 10-8.

chorky777 wrote:

This fight clearly belonged to Fitch. The second was obviously his, and the third was an obvious 10-8.

really? that round was way too close to be obviously anyones

Jamal wrote:

For the guys that voted draw is it because you had the 2nd round as 10-10 or is it because you gave the 3rd to Fitch 10-8?

I gave BJ the first 2, and Fitch the 3rd 10-8 because BJ didnt do anything in that round

After wtching it with a clear head for the second time I have to say a draw was okay. BJ edged out the 2nd round and he got Fitched for all of round 3. Rematch!

bigbeastcardinal12 wrote:

After wtching it with a clear head for the second time I have to say a draw was okay. BJ edged out the 2nd round and he got Fitched for all of round 3. Rematch!

Yeah a draw wasnt the worst thing in the world but I didnt think Fitch won thats for sure. I still think BJ won the 1st 2 and Fitch won the 3rd but I would still say 10-9 but I can see 10-8.

timthebim wrote:

bigbeastcardinal12 wrote:

After wtching it with a clear head for the second time I have to say a draw was okay. BJ edged out the 2nd round and he got Fitched for all of round 3. Rematch!

Yeah a draw wasnt the worst thing in the world but I didnt think Fitch won thats for sure. I still think BJ won the 1st 2 and Fitch won the 3rd but I would still say 10-9 but I can see 10-8.

i knew you guys would come around, that was a draw for the gazillionth time!

killerofchicken wrote:

timthebim wrote:

bigbeastcardinal12 wrote:

After wtching it with a clear head for the second time I have to say a draw was okay. BJ edged out the 2nd round and he got Fitched for all of round 3. Rematch!

Yeah a draw wasnt the worst thing in the world but I didnt think Fitch won thats for sure. I still think BJ won the 1st 2 and Fitch won the 3rd but I would still say 10-9 but I can see 10-8.

i knew you guys would come around, that was a draw for the gazillionth time!

Looks like I am coming around I guess......

http://www.mmamania.com/2011/2/27/2018938/poll-should-bj-penn-vs-jon-fitch-rematch-after-their-main-event-draw

another poll on mmamania, all pretty close.

I had it-

Rd 1= Penn 10-9
Rd 2= Fitch 10-9
Rd 3= Fitch 10-9

So I had it Fitch 29-28.

For someone to get a 10-8 round then the fight has to at least look like it will be stopped. Penn was never in any real danger in the 3rd and the fight was never going to be stopped.

BJ won the first two and lost 10-8 I scored it when I first watched it. Thus - draw.

How are people seeing the second round for Penn? I really don't understand it. Seriously.

chorky777 wrote:

How are people seeing the second round for Penn? I really don't understand it. Seriously.

I'm pretty shocked that so many are saying Penn as well. It was a very close round, I personally gave it to Fitch. But there are alot of people saying BJ which I didn't expect. I expected some but not this many. But to be fair BJ is by far the most popular fighter on this board, it isn't even close.

OU wrote:

chorky777 wrote:

How are people seeing the second round for Penn? I really don't understand it. Seriously.

I'm pretty shocked that so many are saying Penn as well. It was a very close round, I personally gave it to Fitch. But there are alot of people saying BJ which I didn't expect. I expected some but not this many. But to be fair BJ is by far the most popular fighter on this board, it isn't even close.

It's either BJ or Fedor, but it's true that there are quite a few huggers here.

Is BJ really that popular? Like really? He has his fans but seriously...