UFC HW Division vs. Strikeforce HW Division

With SF adding another talented HW to the mix I thought this would be a good poll. Don't look at it really from a resume perspective, simply talent level.

UFC:

Brock
Cain
Dos Santos
Carwin
Nelson
Nog
Mir
Cro cop
Rothwell
Barry
Kongo
Gonzo
Struve

SF:

Fedor
Reem
Werdum
Barnett
Big Foot
AA
Cormier
Del Rosario
Rogers

i went with UFC but it is a very close call

SF has the lineal champ IMO in Werdum but UFCs is deeper IMO

this is too close to call IMO, I'll get back to this one.

I'd love to see them all in a tourny.

Under the UFC banner

There's rumors swirling around about a Fedor vs Bigfoot fight for this fall, thought i'd post that here instead of making another Fedor thread.

I've heard about that, but I might expect Fedor vs. Barnett now

There are also rumors that the UFC is looking into buying SF, wait sorry I was dreaming

How do you guys think Del Rosario does vs Barry and Kongo?

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

I've heard about that, but I might expect Fedor vs. Barnett now

There are also rumors that the UFC is looking into buying SF, wait sorry I was dreaming

wet dreams again?

I think he holds his own, probably beats em both, he's one tough SOB!

killerofchicken wrote:

I think he holds his own, probably beats em both, he's one tough SOB!

Yeah I agree, I think he has a real shot to beat both.

killerofchicken wrote:

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

I've heard about that, but I might expect Fedor vs. Barnett now

There are also rumors that the UFC is looking into buying SF, wait sorry I was dreaming

wet dreams again?

I had to change.....

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

I've heard about that, but I might expect Fedor vs. Barnett now

There are also rumors that the UFC is looking into buying SF, wait sorry I was dreaming

wet dreams again?

I had to change.....

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

How do you guys think Del Rosario does vs Barry and Kongo?

50/50, I need to see him face some tougher comp still.

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

How do you guys think Del Rosario does vs Barry and Kongo?

50/50, I need to see him face some tougher comp still.

Yeah but he has looked tough so far. I can't wait until he fights an upper level guy.

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

soonermark890 wrote:

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

Why do you pick the UFC just because of the 4th best HW in MMA? ha ha... I don't want to get into that though.

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

Why do you pick the UFC just because of the 4th best HW in MMA? ha ha... I don't want to get into that though.

LOL Do you really think he is the 4th best? Who do you have above him? Just a question I am not one of those Brocktards.

soonermark890 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

Why do you pick the UFC just because of the 4th best HW in MMA? ha ha... I don't want to get into that though.

LOL Do you really think he is the 4th best? Who do you have above him? Just a question I am not one of those Brocktards.

Right now I'd pick Fedor, Reem and Cain to beat him. I think the Brock train comes back to reality soon. Not saying he isn't good but he isn't as good as most people seem to think he is...IMO

I think Brock is the best in terms of who beats who, Fedor would have trouble stopping the takedown and Brock is just too huge on top of Fedor for him to mount many sub attempts.

I choose the UFC because of the most overall talent, like top 8 vs. top 8

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

Why do you pick the UFC just because of the 4th best HW in MMA? ha ha... I don't want to get into that though.

LOL Do you really think he is the 4th best? Who do you have above him? Just a question I am not one of those Brocktards.

Right now I'd pick Fedor, Reem and Cain to beat him. I think the Brock train comes back to reality soon. Not saying he isn't good but he isn't as good as most people seem to think he is...IMO

Cain? Really? I see how people can say Fedor and I am still not sure about Reem either but I also have not seen him fight a lot. Man I see this being a problem in the future for MMA just like it is right now in boxing.

soonermark890 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

Why do you pick the UFC just because of the 4th best HW in MMA? ha ha... I don't want to get into that though.

LOL Do you really think he is the 4th best? Who do you have above him? Just a question I am not one of those Brocktards.

Right now I'd pick Fedor, Reem and Cain to beat him. I think the Brock train comes back to reality soon. Not saying he isn't good but he isn't as good as most people seem to think he is...IMO

Cain? Really? I see how people can say Fedor and I am still not sure about Reem either but I also have not seen him fight a lot. Man I see this being a problem in the future for MMA just like it is right now in boxing.

Cain has more MMA fights, more wins in the UFC, never been beaten, beating Nog is arguably as impressive as anything Brock has done. He is younger, closer to his wrestling prime and seems to have great cardio.

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

soonermark890 wrote:

Is this going to be a problem for MMA? What I mean is that is it going to end up like boxing were you cant get the best guys to fight each other because of who promotes them? BTW I say the UFC because of Brock.

Why do you pick the UFC just because of the 4th best HW in MMA? ha ha... I don't want to get into that though.

LOL Do you really think he is the 4th best? Who do you have above him? Just a question I am not one of those Brocktards.

Right now I'd pick Fedor, Reem and Cain to beat him. I think the Brock train comes back to reality soon. Not saying he isn't good but he isn't as good as most people seem to think he is...IMO

Cain? Really? I see how people can say Fedor and I am still not sure about Reem either but I also have not seen him fight a lot. Man I see this being a problem in the future for MMA just like it is right now in boxing.

Cain has more MMA fights, more wins in the UFC, never been beaten, beating Nog is arguably as impressive as anything Brock has done. He is younger, closer to his wrestling prime and seems to have great cardio.

He is also a lot smaller. Brock is also really fast and will manhandle him just like he does everyone else. I dont see how Cain can win outside getting a kinda lucky sub(like Mir did) and even then it will be really hard to do.

Thats cause you're crazy, Cain has wrestled larger guys his entire career, he was also a HW D-1 wrestler(Arizona State). Brock is quick but Cain is quicker. Randy held his own just fine wrestling with Brock until he got clipped in the back of the head and lost his senses he was doing great. Cain is bigger and stronger then Randy he should hold his own fine when it comes to wrestling. Cain has better boxing and a speed advantage.

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

With SF adding another talented HW to the mix I thought this would be a good poll. Don't look at it really from a resume perspective, simply talent level.

UFC:

Brock
Cain
Dos Santos
Carwin
Nelson
Nog
Mir
Cro cop
Rothwell
Barry
Kongo
Gonzo
Struve

SF:

Fedor
Reem
Werdum
Barnett
Big Foot
AA
Cormier
Del Rosario
Rogers

You're forgetting Lashley, Brandon Cash, Lolohea Mahe, but especially Lavar Johnson who headlines events.