Who Is The Greatest MMA Fighter All Time?

Frank was big before I got into MMA. I came around to MMA in 2002 so I never really got to see him. Tapes yeah, but never really saw him in his Prime.

I think Nog should have been one of the choices. I know I'm a homer, but I think his star is brighter than Randy's. Randy may have been more influential but not a beter fighter. He is the only guy to have belts in PRIDE and UFC and thats nothing to sneeze at. If Fedor didn't come down from his spaceship Nog woulda been the Best HW of all time.

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

Not even a good list to boot

delete all other options but Fedro

ok then make a list

Farmer1906 wrote:

Who voted for Hughes?

Well it is a P4P list so I could understand a vote for Hughes more than I could a vote for Cro Cop or Bas. He ruled the UFC forever.

ohiovol62 wrote:

Frank was big before I got into MMA. I came around to MMA in 2002 so I never really got to see him. Tapes yeah, but never really saw him in his Prime.

I think Nog should have been one of the choices. I know I'm a homer, but I think his star is brighter than Randy's. Randy may have been more influential but not a beter fighter. He is the only guy to have belts in PRIDE and UFC and thats nothing to sneeze at. If Fedor didn't come down from his spaceship Nog woulda been the Best HW of all time.

agree and good add for the "other" I thought about adding Big Nog and Sakuraba but only 10 options available.

Agree and actually Fedor beating Nog when Nog was in his prime is a BIG part of Fedors legacy and claim to being the best.

GDPofDRC wrote:

I don't think Anderson has fought better competition then Fedor ever has. My opinion, Anderson has around 5, opponent wise, high level wins, and I'm not talking about punching up a Leben or Dancing with Maia. I have Fedor and GSP with about 7 or 8 of those types of wins. It's all subjective of course. I think the way Anderson fights is more justifiable argument for him being the best MMA fighter ever.

Exactly, how Fedor fights is also justifiable argument for him being the best MMA fighter ever aswell. Anderson never plays to his opponents strengths. Fedor does it all the time.

Ninja\Rua/Fan wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

I don't think Anderson has fought better competition then Fedor ever has. My opinion, Anderson has around 5, opponent wise, high level wins, and I'm not talking about punching up a Leben or Dancing with Maia. I have Fedor and GSP with about 7 or 8 of those types of wins. It's all subjective of course. I think the way Anderson fights is more justifiable argument for him being the best MMA fighter ever.

Exactly, how Fedor fights is also justifiable argument for him being the best MMA fighter ever aswell. Anderson never plays to his opponents strengths. Fedor does it all the time.

Yep. He out strikes strikers and submitted a judo silver medalist

Birdofthad wrote:

ohiovol62 wrote:

Frank was big before I got into MMA. I came around to MMA in 2002 so I never really got to see him. Tapes yeah, but never really saw him in his Prime.

I think Nog should have been one of the choices. I know I'm a homer, but I think his star is brighter than Randy's. Randy may have been more influential but not a beter fighter. He is the only guy to have belts in PRIDE and UFC and thats nothing to sneeze at. If Fedor didn't come down from his spaceship Nog woulda been the Best HW of all time.

agree and good add for the "other" I thought about adding Big Nog and Sakuraba but only 10 options available.

Agree and actually Fedor beating Nog when Nog was in his prime is a BIG part of Fedors legacy and claim to being the best.

You're prolly right. Ya got to stop somewhere. With all the great fighters out there, someone is gonna be left out

Yeah.

Why bump both threads? A link in the new thread would do just fine.

mr bumpty do

All these rules are suffocating me!!!

nobody likes too many bumps... man, that rhymes, i should rap

atleast spread it out, I know you may be bored but that was like 8 bumps in 5 min. Go run a lap between bumps.

HAHA

You 2 were boring me so I had to entertain myself.