What do you think about torture?

You like it?

Is waterboarding torture?



Ed Clay gets waterboarded after hearing in the GOP CBS debate that many
candidates didn't think waterboarding was torture. He goes through two
seperate sessions that they teach, the second being much worse...

I do think waterboarding is torture, but I'm fine with us using it.

totally against torture but it will always be a part of human culture as we don't know any better

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

So your obviously with the train of thought that we did this to harmless people who just admitted to shit to stop the torture. Well I bet I could get someone to admit anything I wanted with a gun in my hand too so lets not use them either.

MMAEYES wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

So your obviously with the train of thought that we did this to harmless people who just admitted to shit to stop the torture. Well I bet I could get someone to admit anything I wanted with a gun in my hand too so lets not use them either.

So your basically saying here torture is ineffective but you condone it still?

killerofchicken wrote:

totally against torture but it will always be a part of human culture as we don't know any better

I'm sorry but some people deserve to be tortured.

Whatever works.

GDPofDRC wrote:

MMAEYES wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

So your obviously with the train of thought that we did this to harmless people who just admitted to shit to stop the torture. Well I bet I could get someone to admit anything I wanted with a gun in my hand too so lets not use them either.

So your basically saying here torture is ineffective but you condone it still?

No I'm saying if thats your arguement against torture then we should lay down our arms too. I don't think it was ineffective at all

MMAEYES wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

totally against torture but it will always be a part of human culture as we don't know any better

I'm sorry but some people deserve to be tortured.

you are entitled to your opinion.

MMAEYES wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

MMAEYES wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

So your obviously with the train of thought that we did this to harmless people who just admitted to shit to stop the torture. Well I bet I could get someone to admit anything I wanted with a gun in my hand too so lets not use them either.

So your basically saying here torture is ineffective but you condone it still?

No I'm saying if thats your arguement against torture then we should lay down our arms too. I don't think it was ineffective at all

But if you argue torture can make someone say anything regardless if is true or not then how exactly is it effective?

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

anything and everything, i'd make shit up if i had to... the fact is, 98% of these guys that are getting tortured at Guantanamo have NO info that could help the US.

EDIT

killerofchicken wrote:

MMAEYES wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

totally against torture but it will always be a part of human culture as we don't know any better

I'm sorry but some people deserve to be tortured.

you are entitled to your opinion.

Yep and you to yours my friend

killerofchicken wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

anything and everything, i'd make shit up if i had to... the fact is, 98 of these guys that are getting tortured at Guantanamo have NO info that could help the US.

If that's true way has Obama never made good on his promise to save those guys from the evil right wingers who put them there, anwser me that.

MMAEYES wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

anything and everything, i'd make shit up if i had to... the fact is, 98 of these guys that are getting tortured at Guantanamo have NO info that could help the US.

If that's true way has Obama never made good on his promise to save those guys from the evil right wingers who put them there, anwser me that.

You still haven't answered why you support torture, which you argue is ineffective.

MMAEYES wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

anything and everything, i'd make shit up if i had to... the fact is, 98 of these guys that are getting tortured at Guantanamo have NO info that could help the US.

If that's true way has Obama never made good on his promise to save those guys from the evil right wingers who put them there, anwser me that.

dude if you haven't noticed, candidates will say ANYTHING to get elected! and then they when they do... exactly

It's kinda kinky, S & M doesn't float my boat.

GDPofDRC wrote:

MMAEYES wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

anything and everything, i'd make shit up if i had to... the fact is, 98 of these guys that are getting tortured at Guantanamo have NO info that could help the US.

If that's true way has Obama never made good on his promise to save those guys from the evil right wingers who put them there, anwser me that.

You still haven't answered why you support torture, which you argue is ineffective.

My bad had to go do something, I'm back. Again I don't think it was ineffective I believe it worked, now did it work 100% I don't know but we do know that terror plots have been stopped imo thanks to one of our guys doing what has to be done. Can you make a person say whatever you want with this tactic? Yeah but why the fuck would we just make these guys admit shit that isn't true, I mean really think about it, what would we gain? So you think were just housing these fuckers just cause we feel like it?

I never run away from a good arguement, bring it

MMAEYES wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

MMAEYES wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

What things do you think you would say if you were waterboarded?

anything and everything, i'd make shit up if i had to... the fact is, 98 of these guys that are getting tortured at Guantanamo have NO info that could help the US.

If that's true way has Obama never made good on his promise to save those guys from the evil right wingers who put them there, anwser me that.

You still haven't answered why you support torture, which you argue is ineffective.

My bad had to go do something, I'm back. Again I don't think it was ineffective I believe it worked, now did it work 100% I don't know but we do know that terror plots have been stopped imo thanks to one of our guys doing what has to be done. Can you make a person say whatever you want with this tactic? Yeah but why the fuck would we just make these guys admit shit that isn't true, I mean really think about it, what would we gain? So you think were just housing these fuckers just cause we feel like it?

that is a very good question

So why do you think we would do that killer? I mean what purpose would their be that would benifit our "evil leaders" to just hold randum dudes that didn't do anything? Do you really think were just Religious nazi's or some shit? Just happy to have some muslims in a prison? Cause I don't believe that for a second.

MMAEYES wrote:

So why do you think we would do that killer? I mean what purpose would their be that would benifit our "evil leaders" to just hold randum dudes that didn't do anything? Do you really think were just Religious nazi's or some shit? Just happy to have some muslims in a prison? Cause I don't believe that for a second.

these dudes are sheep herders from middle of nowhere lol, they know nothing

So you do think were Religious nazi's?

Well you're effectively contradicting yourself when you say a tortured person will say anything. Or do think torture only yields honest results?

The point is, if you are tortured, you're eventually guilty, regardless if that is the case or not, so how is that a justifiable act?

MMAEYES wrote:

So you do think were Religious nazi's?

no, but ill have you know that half of your country does think so