Gil vs Noons for LW Title

Think it'd be a great fight and better than Gil/Thompson 3, Noons lost but fought great tonight

Noons can't make the weight anymore.

For a Title shot he could

I'd rather see him at Welterweight against my boy Daley.

He's got plenty of awesome fights at WW. Cyborg is a great next step.

WW is thin in SF, and so is LW, Noons vs. Gil would be awesome

LA wrote:

WW is thin in SF, and so is LW, Noons vs. Gil would be awesome

WW is good in SF. This aint the UFC homie, for a promotion in their shoes at their stage, doing well. We understand you like this fight, I promise. Cool.

It's good?

Good being a relative term. Yes. Is it the UFC? No. Is that inherently the measuring stick for good?

But LW is looking worse if Thompson and Gil may go at it for the 3rd time, Noons and Gil would be a great fight, I know you know this.

LA wrote:

But LW is looking worse if Thompson and Gil may go at it for the 3rd time, Noons and Gil would be a great fight, I know you know this.

It would be a great fight, but since when do epic rubber matches suck?

IDK Healy then a close fight with JZ, some say JZ won, and back to a Title shot? it isn't bad at all, I'd just rather see something different.

Actually before that I'd rather see Gil vs. Alvarez.

Ali wrote:

Noons can't make the weight anymore.

He just made it less than 2 months ago. I don't think that's too big of an issue

Noons actually failed to make weight two months ago...and his fight before that...and the fight before that. I'd like to see Noons fight Gil, but i can't think of a time Noons ever made 155. EliteXC's LW was at 160 and all of Noons fights have been catchweights.

I would rather see Melendez vs. Noons although i think JT will be a little better than he was in the second fight coming off a long layoff.

LA wrote:

IDK Healy then a close fight with JZ, some say JZ won, and back to a Title shot? it isn't bad at all, I'd just rather see something different.

Actually before that I'd rather see Gil vs. Alvarez.

But is beating Gurgel, getting and losing a title fight at170, and then a title shot at 155 a better option?

I think noons needs to stay at WW. With he, Daley, Smith, Cyborg, Woodley, Bowley, Saffeideine, Coy, their WW division is pretty good, bunch of good fights for Noons there. This division went from soft, to pretty good, pretty quickly.

SF will probably keep Gil busy in Japan, while they build up their 155. I wouldn't say it's weak, though right now, it's probably lacking in a clear cut interesting title fight. They need to get the Alverez fight done. Problem fixed right there.

He was on a nice winning streak though, and fighting the WW Champ that close is good for something, I think that'd be a great fight, bu would actually still rather see Alvarez first.

WW is weak, that's hardly an impressive bunch there

LA wrote:

He was on a nice winning streak though, and fighting the WW Champ that close is good for something, I think that'd be a great fight, bu would actually still rather see Alvarez first.

WW is weak, that's hardly an impressive bunch there

Why is that? Kos, bored his way to a title shot by laying on daley, who just prior KO'd a dude who was in line for a title fight. Is he now garbage again cause he is not in the UFC? Cyborg and Smith are a couple brawling and respectable 185ers, who have made the cut to 170, where one would think each will prove more successful. Woodley's 9-0, 8 finishes, excellent wrestling credentials. Coy, gave Woodley all he could handle, and is himself 8-3. Tarec is 10-2, very good kickboxer, would love to see him vs your boy Zaromskis.

It's a solid division. Top 4 of Diaz, Daley, Noons, Woodley is solid. And the division def not lacking in interesting matchups. Noons vs Daley, Smith or Cyborg would be sweet.

You're just trying to sell it hard cause that's what you do, you know that's a weak division.

Kos would run through that division in his sleep by the way.

LA wrote:

You're just trying to sell it hard cause that's what you do, you know that's a weak division.

Kos would run through that division in his sleep by the way.

He'd run through woodley? U sure?

and we all know you are UFC nuthugger #1a on this board, so don't go pointing fingers.

Yes, now Woodley is beating Kos cause he finsihed Galvao who has looked like shit lately? even in wins. Funny stuff though

LA wrote:

Yes, now Woodley is beating Kos cause he finsihed Galvao who has looked like shit lately? even in wins. Funny stuff though

Why not? What is Kos's strengh? Wrestling. Is he a better wrestler then Woodley? arguable. I recently seen Kos get KO'd by a JJ specialist. Not as though the guy has beaten a who's who of MMA fighters. Daley is his best win.

Man sometimes I think you just argue to argue, either that or you're way to high on SF. Woodley has beaten no one so far, now he's beating Kos... Woodley really lost his fight to Coy, that was a bad decision.

LA wrote:

Man sometimes I think you just argue to argue, either that or you're way to high on SF. Woodley has beaten no one so far, now he's beating Kos... Woodley really lost his fight to Coy, that was a bad decision.

says who?

and Kos's last 5 fights are vs, Yoshida(was just KO'd in Bellator), KO'd by Thiago, beats Trigg(wow) beats Anthony Johnson, beats Daley(by boredom). Now he's fighting for the title?

Are these guys really on another level then Woodely or Coy? Should we deride SF's 170 division when the biggest promotion in the sport is a giving a title fight to a guy whose last 5 fights are listed above?

And don't worry about why I argue, maybe worry about why u r such a ufc nut hugger.

Man Coy is now a top guy huh? losing fights to Paul Bradley and Brain Foster?

And rewatch the fight, it wasn't a good decision

And you should worry about why you're such a SF nuthugger

LA wrote:

Man Coy is now a top guy huh? losing fights to Paul Bradley and Brain Foster?

And rewatch the fight, it wasn't a good decision

And you should worry about why you're such a SF nuthugger

I watched the fight. I thought Woodley won. Close fight though.

Never said Coy was a top guy. But I know Yoshida and Trigg are not top guys. Johnson ain't neither. Coy can't hang with these 3? He'd prob wrestle Daley up too.

And I like SF(and Bellator, and the HDNet fights) cause I don't have to pay $50 bucks a shot to see good fights between good fighters. I could argue quite a few Bellator guys as being high quality as well.