McCall-DJ was supposed to be a draw; rematch being scheduled

This is familiar. Judging system doesn't work well, an idea any idea mentioned '??? No no no" nothing else.

Why does the current system work so well then?

There's nothing wrong with the system. Honestly it doesn't matter what system is implemented if the judges are uneducated as to what they are seeing. If they aren't familiar with the techniques they are witnessing then it's not going to matter if the scoring system is a 10 point must, half point, hundred point, or even just judging the fight as a whole.

Exactly. Complicating a system already poorly understood fixes what how exactly? If your kid is sucking ass already in algebra you dont jump his ass up to calculus.

More clear definitions of what should be scored and how should be crafted. More education for judges and accountability for shitty judging(FIRE DUDES WHO SUCK) ,and once that happens, then we move to a half point system. No passing new laws when the ones on the book are not enforced.

Ludo wrote:

Honestly it doesn't matter what system is implemented if the judges are uneducated as to what they are seeing.

Agreed

I def think McCall won that fight, I gave Mouse the 2nd, but imo McCall was the clear winner of the other two rounds.

"I have a beef with judging and refereeing. To me, I don't think you should ever be able to judge or referee unless you have a physical background in that art. I'm a big fan of professional football, but I'm not qualified to be a judge. In MMA, it's the flavor of the month and everyone wants to be a judge or a referee. I see a lot of referees that could use a little bit more instruction. I think it should be mandatory for these judges to go to Mauy Thai schools, go to Judo schools, go to Greco Roman schools, go to freestyle wrestling schools, Kempo, Shotokan, Taekwondo, all those schools and learn a little bit of everything. You want to know if a body slam hurts more than a left hook and how much damage can something get? You have to be on the mat or in the ring to know the difference. It's my humble opinion." -- Judo master Gene LeBell

Ol Gene Himself. 114 year of Martial Arts Knowledge.

Farmer1906 wrote:

GDPofDRC wrote:

Ian mcall today is still the number 1 fly weight in the world.

According to who?

Joe is #1 in my ranking.

http://www.sherdog.com/news/rankings/9/Sherdogs-Official-Mixed-Martial-Arts-Rankings-40911

That is who, and Sherdog is NEVER EVA FUCKING WRONG!!!!!!!!!

Joe is gonna get run by either Mouse or Creepy.

OU wrote:

Joe is gonna get run by either Mouse or Creepy.

Nope. Joe will dictate the action and get his hands on the speedy guys.

Farmer1906 wrote:

OU wrote:

Joe is gonna get run by either Mouse or Creepy.

Nope. Joe will dictate the action and get his hands on the speedy guys.

We shall see. I think either Mouse or Creepy handle him.