Would Jake Shields give GSP or Anderson Silva a tougher fight?

I think GSP is going to destroy Jake Shields but would Anderson Silva do the same or would Jake's grappling give Anderson Silva a tough time?

Which of the 2 fighters do you think Jake Shields would give a closer tougher fight?

I voted Anderson Silva. Shields is a natural 185 and his grappling would give Anderson a tougher fight then it would against GSP.

GSP

Silva, he could take him down and control him, possibly sub him there too

and he's proven tough enough to take a beating and come back and still dominate

Shields' victory against Henderson at MW was impressive after what happened to him in the first round.

He at least stands a chance to give Silva problems with takeodwns.

GSP on the other hand is good enough to negate those takedowns with his own or wrestling defense.

Both would destroy Shields blindfolded on the feet.

I think GSP has more trouble with Shields. I think Jake will get a takedown or two on GSP and will also have a few sub attempts. Most people give Jake no shot vs GSP but I actually think he has a good chance to pull an upset.

You say that every gsp fight Tim.

Silva would decimate Jake standing.

Ali wrote:

Silva would decimate Jake standing.

Most strikers would if it stayed standing.

freakzilla wrote:

You say that every gsp fight Tim.

I know