Dunham vs Sherk

If Dunham is the victor, where does that place him in the top 10? I think he moves into the top 5, based on Sherk's record of opponents and his toughness, barring this string of injuries.

Lightweight Rankings if Dunham wins-

01. Frankie Edgar
02. BJ Penn
03. Gray Maynard
04. Kenny Florian
04. Gilbert Melendez
06. Eddie Alvarez
07. Shinya Aoki
08. George Sotiropolous
09. Evan Dunham
10. Takanori Gomi

Lightweight Rankings if Sherk wins-

Lightweight-

01. Frankie Edgar
02. BJ Penn
03. Gray Maynard
04. Kenny Florian
04. Gilbert Melendez
06. Eddie Alvarez
07. Shinya Aoki
08. Sean Sherk
09. George Sotiropolous
10. Takanori Gomi

You keep putting Aussie George to high. His biggest wins are over Kert Pelligrino and Joe Daddy, Dunham will have beaten Sherk (former Champion), Tyson Griffin and Efrain Escudero (TUF winner). I think Dunham will have to be over him Freak.

Andrew the Raider King wrote:

You keep putting Aussie George to high. His biggest wins are over Kert Pelligrino and Joe Daddy, Dunham will have beaten Sherk (former Champion), Tyson Griffin and Efrain Escudero (TUF winner). I think Dunham will have to be over him Freak.

I was thinking the same thing, I personally would have Dunham over George.

I see Dunham dominating Sherk tomorrow.

Ali_1748 wrote:

I see Dunham dominating Sherk tomorrow.

Why? How many people have dominated Sherk?

Dunham is a good fighter but the closer the fight gets the more confident I am that Sherk is going to actually use his wrestling and walk away with a decision tomorrow

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

I see Dunham dominating Sherk tomorrow.

Why? How many people have dominated Sherk?

His size,reach and youth will be too much for Sherk to deal with. At 37 Sherk is well past his best, and his body is completely falling apart.

Ali_1748 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

I see Dunham dominating Sherk tomorrow.

Why? How many people have dominated Sherk?

His size,reach and youth will be too much for Sherk to deal with. At 37 Sherk is well past his best, and his body is completely falling apart.

Really? Is that just a guess on your part? I know Frankie beat him but he didn't exactly dominate. You think his age is just going to hit him all the sudden this fight? Sherk has fought at WW against guys like Nick Diaz, the size and length is nothing Sherk hasn't seen before. I think you are jumping to conclusions, for no reason really.

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

I see Dunham dominating Sherk tomorrow.

Why? How many people have dominated Sherk?

His size,reach and youth will be too much for Sherk to deal with. At 37 Sherk is well past his best, and his body is completely falling apart.

Really? Is that just a guess on your part? I know Frankie beat him but he didn't exactly dominate. You think his age is just going to hit him all the sudden this fight? Sherk has fought at WW against guys like Nick Diaz, the size and length is nothing Sherk hasn't seen before. I think you are jumping to conclusions, for no reason really.

For fuck sake will you knock it off. Every time I comment on here you're on my ass because I have different opinions from you.

If you don't agree with me that's fine, but stop being such a disrespectful prick all the times with the snide catty comments.

Sean hasn't fought in a year, he's been plagued by lots of injuries, he's about to compete in his 39th professional fight, sooner or later all that wear and tear will catch him with him.

Ali_1748 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

OUSOONERSOU wrote:

Ali_1748 wrote:

I see Dunham dominating Sherk tomorrow.

Why? How many people have dominated Sherk?

His size,reach and youth will be too much for Sherk to deal with. At 37 Sherk is well past his best, and his body is completely falling apart.

Really? Is that just a guess on your part? I know Frankie beat him but he didn't exactly dominate. You think his age is just going to hit him all the sudden this fight? Sherk has fought at WW against guys like Nick Diaz, the size and length is nothing Sherk hasn't seen before. I think you are jumping to conclusions, for no reason really.

For fuck sake will you knock it off. Every time I comment on here you're on my ass because I have different opinions from you.

Are you just upset because I use facts to make you opinion look ridiculous? Why don't u just educate yourself and come with a better debate. Don't get made at me because I call out your weak arguments and support it with actual facts. Step your game up son.

Go fuck yourself you little ginger runt.

Ali_1748 wrote:

Sean hasn't fought in a year, he's been plagued by lots of injuries, he's about to compete in his 39th professional fight, sooner or later all that wear and tear will catch him with him.

So you are just guessing that today is the day? Sherk has only 4 losses in his entire career and those were to Frankie, BJ, GSP and Hughes. All Champs or former Champs. I'm just saying to say a young gun will dominate is just a bit ignorant IMO. You are just looking at his age and assuming he can't hang anymore.

Ali_1748 wrote:

Go fuck yourself you little ginger runt.

Great comeback. Maybe you should just stick to the boxing side so you don't embarrass yourself.

Andrew the Raider King wrote:

You keep putting Aussie George to high. His biggest wins are over Kert Pelligrino and Joe Daddy, Dunham will have beaten Sherk (former Champion), Tyson Griffin and Efrain Escudero (TUF winner). I think Dunham will have to be over him Freak.

You're probably right. Just a little Aussie pride

You're the only person he seems to have issues with my opinions on the sport I've grown to love, alot of the other members on here have knowledge that dwarf mine but they don't feel the need to act like dick and attempt to belittle me.

Ali_1748 wrote:

You're the only person he seems to have issues with my opinions on the sport I've grown to love, alot of the other members on here have knowledge that dwarf mine but they don't feel the need to act like dick and attempt to belittle me.

They are nicer people then I am. Why bitch though? Just absorb the knowledge and move on. I wasn't aware you were unable to debate your opinions on the subject.