Ninjas Place Immortals 2000 - 2010 Voting

Chuck Liddell

Fedor Emelianenko

Wanderlei Silva

Matt Hughes

Anderson Silva

Big Nog

BJ Penn

Jens Pulver

Takanori Gomi

BJ Penn
Chuck Liddell
Fedor Emelienanko
Antonio Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira
Randy Couture
Vitor Belfort
Matt Hughes
Wanderlei Silva
Matt Lindland
Dan Henderson
Mauricio Rua
Mirko Filipovic
Anderson Silva
Akihiri Gono
Takanori Gomi
Jens Pulver
Caol Uno
Yves Edwards
Tito Ortiz
Kazushi Sakuraba
Jeremy Horn

BJ Penn
Chuck Liddell
Fedor Emelienanko
Antonio Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira
Randy Couture
Vitor Belfort
Matt Hughes
Wanderlei Silva
Matt Lindland
Dan Henderson
Mauricio Rua
Mirko Filipovic
Anderson Silva
Akihiri Gono
Takanori Gomi
Jens Pulver
Caol Uno
Yves Edwards
Tito Ortiz
Kazushi Sakuraba
Jeremy Horn

This is a hall of fame class. Now distill a small group of Immortals out of that.

Wolfgangsta wrote:

BJ Penn
Chuck Liddell
Fedor Emelienanko
Antonio Rodrigo "Minotauro" Nogueira
Randy Couture
Vitor Belfort
Matt Hughes
Wanderlei Silva
Matt Lindland
Dan Henderson
Mauricio Rua
Mirko Filipovic
Anderson Silva
Akihiri Gono
Takanori Gomi
Jens Pulver
Caol Uno
Yves Edwards
Tito Ortiz
Kazushi Sakuraba
Jeremy Horn

This is a hall of fame class. Now distill a small group of Immortals out of that.

Then I'd probably go with:

Chuck Liddell
Fedor Emelienanko
BJ Penn
Anderson Silva
Matt Hughes
Wanderlei Silva
Randy Couture

I think we should limit it to 10.

Fedor Emelienanko
Randy Couture
Matt Hughes
Chuck Liddell
Anderson Silva
Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira
Wanderlei Silva
Georges St.Pierre
BJ Penn
Jens Pulver

bump

Thanks bird. We should have 10 total though.

There shouldn't be a limit, just should be those who deserve it, whether over or under 10

Damn LA Shogun doesnt get in?

A Prix winner and one time Champ? thought this was immortals? Machida would be in if he was.

Shit he has beaten like 3 of the guys u said let in plus his Grand Prix title and he is still the UFC LHW champ as we speak. He actually beat Machida twice if u ask me.

I think limit to 10 and then enter 5 every year.

Speak about it in my topic so we can figure this out.

He beat one of the guys I highlighted, and Chuck was at the end of the line in his career. Shogun is great but this is immortals, how many guys to we open it up for if he gets in?

Im just being devils advocate anyways but he is just as deserving as Wandy in my opinion.

Rua doen't get in now. That's why I said limit it to 10 for now.

LA may be right about Shogun but I think u can make a case for him.

Hasn't done it for many years yet. Too many injuries. Machida doesn't get in either.

Deserving as Wandy?

But the 14 guys I bolded and you can make a case for a couple more, all belong this last decade.

LA wrote:

Deserving as Wandy?

But the 14 guys I bolded and you can make a case for a couple more, all belong this last decade.

Just because some of the bad losses Wandy has. He loss acouple fights in seconds. Really is that immortal?

He's past his peak. His previous accomplishments get him in easily. Guys we should just vote for the ten most deserving.

Im not really a big fan of the whole immortal thing so I wont vote anyways so really I shouldnt be on here defending or bashing any1!

Look at Wandy through the 2000's

You're not bashing anything Timbo, just posting your opinion, but the Lakers are thrashing the Pistons.