HW Top 20 - Post UFC 146 - Voting Closes Friday 6/1/2012

1. JDS
2. Cain
3. Overeem
4. Werdum
5. Cormier
6. Mir
7. Carwin
8. Barnett
9. Nog
10. Big Foot
11. Fedor
12. Browne
13. Konrad
14. Miocic
15. Nelson
16. Hunt
17. Struve
18. Russow (feel bad for ranking so low, but I think his record is inflated)
19. Kongo
20. Kharitonov

GDPofDRC wrote:

If you haven't don it yet, do it tonight and I will tally it up and post.

We got 8 rankings, the over under is at 9.5.

GDPofDRC wrote:

Birdofthad wrote:

his problem is he has fought once a year every year since 2009, he has got to change that.

This and he still hasn't really got any definitive win that puts him over any of the actual top 20 fighters in the division right now. JOE is kinda old and hasn't won a fight since returning from a 6 year break, Madsesn has been MIA for a while now since their fight, which was kinda eh, and Justin McCully, c'mon, filler. Survivng a beat down from Duffee 2 years ago is still his defining moment. He is in a range of 15 to 22 for me and not getting into my top 20 until he show me something more convincing.

I can understand that, but what I think of him is that he is a talented guy who can bang, and man can he take a punch.

Why are people not ranking Carwin? The lay off?

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Why are people not ranking Carwin? The lay off?

That's what they said. I still think he's top 10.

Well, hes cleared and has asked for a fight this year. Which would qualify him for ranking again.

It was just horrible timing is what it was. I was ready to write Carwin off as retired since he was in a very long layoff and no word of a comeback. Then hours after posting, he announces he is coming back soon. Should have edited it before I left work Friday.

OU wrote:

It was just horrible timing is what it was. I was ready to write Carwin off as retired since he was in a very long layoff and no word of a comeback. Then hours after posting, he announces he is coming back soon. Should have edited it before I left work Friday.

Where would you have him?

freakzilla wrote:

OU wrote:

It was just horrible timing is what it was. I was ready to write Carwin off as retired since he was in a very long layoff and no word of a comeback. Then hours after posting, he announces he is coming back soon. Should have edited it before I left work Friday.

Where would you have him?

It's tough with his layoff. But I'd probably go with 9th ahead of Konrad.