MMA RANKINGS - CHAPTER 2...

10 or 20, it's tough either way to like what I got.

I think Bobbitt hit all the right numbers with the names Dude.

oggy420 wrote:

im just curious on how you get top 10 status when you've never even been in the ring with a top 10 opponent

by looking uber impressive against the guys your matched up against.

Official Rankings

1. Fedor - 93
1. GSP - 93
2. Matt Hughes - 85
3. Wanderlei Silva - 78
3. Anderson Silva - 78
4. BJ Penn - 73
5. Frank Shamrock - 65
6. Chuck Liddell - 61
7. Shogun Rua - 60
8. Randy Couture - 38
9. Kazushi Sakuraba - 27
10. Royce Gracie - 25

Honorable Mention : Dan Henderson - 24, Jens Pulver 23, Big Nog - 23

other add theirs and then some of those ties shold change

Official Rankings

1. Fedor - 93
1. GSP - 93
2. Matt Hughes - 85
3. Wanderlei Silva - 78
3. Anderson Silva - 78
4. BJ Penn - 73
5. Frank Shamrock - 65
6. Chuck Liddell - 61
7. Shogun Rua - 60
8. Randy Couture - 38
9. Kazushi Sakuraba - 27
10. Royce Gracie - 25

Honorable Mention : Dan Henderson - 24, Jens Pulver 23, Big Nog - 23

I still don't understand how Chuck and be 8th and Wand 4th.

Wandy was in everybody that voteds top 5 and one top 6, Chuck was in top 5 one time, top 10 3 times, and top 15 one time

Birdofthad wrote:

Wandy was in everybody that voteds top 5 and one top 6, Chuck was in top 5 one time, top 10 3 times, and top 15 one time

No I understand the scoring, but I can't understand how people see it that way.

I think Chuck has the better career and better skills. Even when he was done (career wise), he still beat Wand head to head. I love Wand and see him as the clear #2 LHW of all time. I can also see some people seeing Wand slightly better, but 4 spots higher in P4P? No way.

well you wouldnt like my rankings!

looks good

can a mod make this a sticky please?

GSP and Fedor are a tie? really? Also if there are 2 number 1's then Matt Hughes is number 3 not number 2. Otherwise good work.

freak i already knew people would probab ly complain about how i did the ties, which is why i included the honorable mention, so that you can see how it would have been if we did top 15

Looks good except for no Big Nog. He's had a better career and more top wins than Randy. I didn't vote in this so I only have myself to blame.

Just saw this listing/write up. Fits in with this thread I think.

MMA Top 50 fighters

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/400131-top-50-fighters-in-mma-history-is-fedor-emelianenko-the-greatest-ever

Different than our list, but pretty good mix of old and new.

Heavyweight-

01. Brock Lesnar
02. Fedor Emelianenko
03. Shane Carwin
04. Cain Velasquez
05. Allistar Overeem
06. Fabricio Werdum
07. Frank Mir
08. Junior dos Santos
09. Brett Rogers
10. Big Nog

The real question is how far does Werdum move up for beating the GOAT

Dos Santos knock him out cold and would do it again

Brock
Fedor
Carwin
Cain
Dos Santos
Overeem
Werdum
Mir
Big Foot
Big Nog

Yeah but Werdurm beat the GOAT so he has to be ranked higher than Dos Santos.

Moves way up, yeah he's one dimensional, but he now has the best win of anyone in the division.

But Dos Santos knocked him out cold so he has to be higher than Werdum

Brock
Carwin
Cain
JDS
Werdum
Fedor

tolivendiewithLA wrote:

But Dos Santos knocked him out cold so he has to be higher than Werdum

By your logic that means you should have Dos Santos higher than Fedor.

P4P Cyborg passes him up now. GSP and Spider do also. That bitch is bad!

Brock has always been the toughtest HW imo. Werdum got lucky either way. Fedor is still the GOAT and he got caught and made a stupid mistake to a BJJ guy who hadn't even started sweating. Fedor is not that dumb!