Best QB in the NFL:

Here's something that's actually debatable, I thought about going with more than the 3 obvious ones, but thought guys like Big Ben, Warner, Eli, Rodgers ect wouldn't get enough of the vote, so just went with other.

Tom Brady - 3x Superbowl Champion, 2x Superbowl MVP, 1x NFL MVP, all-time single season TD leader

Peyton Manning - 1x Superbowl Champion, 1x Superbowl MVP, 3x NFL MVP (tied most all-time) on pace to break all of Favre's records and while doing it better.

Drew Brees - Not as accomplished as Brady and Manning, but there's no denying Drew has mad game, basically he could be the new Marino, consistency over his last like 4-5 seasons with around 28+ TD's and always around 4400+ passing yrds. Won Offensive Player of the Year in 2008

right now the best qb in the league is drew brees

soon to be on this list Mark Sanchez!

oggy420 wrote:

right now the best qb in the league is drew brees

soon to be on this list Mark Sanchez!

I have to go with Brees but really all three of these guys are a cut above the rest of the QBs in the league.

A healthy Brady is still the best in the business IMO

There are arguments for all of them. Depends on how you define best. I still voted Brady.

Went Brady, but I'm shocked at the vote so far, zero for Peyton and Brees one off Brady, I would have thought it would go Brady, Peyton then Brees, and my vote would be that aswell

Im shocked at these results. Without a doubt it is Peyton Manning that gets my vote. He has run that offense like a well-oiled machine better than i've seen anyone operate their offenses.

Yeah you can make the argument for Brees and how Brady has won those superbowls...but Manning has played like this and won for about a decade, and has had a shitty defense every year to boot. Brady has always had a good defense to back him up wheras Manning has not.

Brees would be 3rd for me on this list. Until he wins a ring, I have no choice.

Peyton & Tom will each go down as 2 of the greatest of all time at QB if not the best 2 of all time.

Brees is awesome and racks up yards, but his lack of success in the playoffs ruin his chances of being remembered as greatness.

yea Peyton is probably better than Brees, but Brady sucks balls!

oggy420 wrote:

yea Peyton is probably better than Brees, but Brady sucks balls!

Spoken like a true Jets fan

ten months ago Favre was his vote, now it's Mark Sanchez...


who is it next year?

Wolfgangsta wrote:

ten months ago Favre was his vote, now it's Mark Sanchez...


who is it next year?

Mark Sanchez is for real, you guys can laugh all you want cause we'll be laughing all the way to the superbowl!

Right now it's Peyton Manning.

Tom Brady isn't playing like his normal self or else I would have said him.

I used to have reasons like NoRegret's for saying Manning over Brady, but then Brady got an all star receiver and look what he did. Manning has always had a great offense around him. Brady has been unquestionably more clutch over his career, although Manning has become money in the clutch as well, and that's mostly throwing to guys like Troy Brown.

rite now i take Tom Brady..



soon to be on this list Mark Sanchez!

im with ya on that oggy!

Farmer1906 wrote:

Peyton & Tom will each go down as 2 of the greatest of all time at QB if not the best 2 of all time.

Brees is awesome and racks up yards, but his lack of success in the playoffs ruin his chances of being remembered as greatness.

Interesting that u were willing to make that statement relatively early in Brees career, yet Peytons one SB was enough to put him in the top 2. And of coarse now they are tied.

I was having a discussion the other day with a guy about greatest QB of all time. He was pushing Peyton, I pointed to his having only one SB. He also pushed Favre which I thought was ridiculous(and he said all the espn guys thought that, which I also see as riciculous).

I still lean Montana, but the way the game is played now I wonder if the pure #'s of today will push him out of the argument despite his abilities to get the job done in the biggest of spots.

3 years after this thread was made I think its safe to say Mark Sanchez still isnt even a top 10 QB.

timthebim wrote:

3 years after this thread was made I think its safe to say Mark Sanchez still isnt even a top 10 QB.

Not even close, but now you add in the newest rookie class and Sanchez might fall out of the top 20.

Farmer1906 wrote:

timthebim wrote:

3 years after this thread was made I think its safe to say Mark Sanchez still isnt even a top 10 QB.

Not even close, but now you add in the newest rookie class and Sanchez might fall out of the top 20.

I agree. There are some great young QBs out there, some already better then Sanchez.

Still early in the season, but it's getting to the point where Sanchez's spot as a starter for next year is looking shakey. And I don't expect Tebow being the guy to take his place.

Granted he is in a tough spot, with a bad o-line, no running backs, one decent receiver and a coaching staff that shows little faith in him, but the lack of improvement out of him is troubling(at least if you are a Jet fan it is).

captain organic wrote:

Still early in the season, but it's getting to the point where Sanchez's spot as a starter for next year is looking shakey. And I don't expect Tebow being the guy to take his place.

Granted he is in a tough spot, with a bad o-line, no running backs, one decent receiver and a coaching staff that shows little faith in him, but the lack of improvement out of him is troubling(at least if you are a Jet fan it is).

Right now Vick seems to be the QB on the hook. It's been one of the stories all week. Doesn't help that Eagle fans fell in love with Nick Foles in the pre-season.

Through 4 games, #49ers QB Alex Smith is on pace for 20:4 TD-to-INT ratio and 3,136 passing yards.

Farmer1906 wrote:

Through 4 games, #49ers QB Alex Smith is on pace for 20:4 TD-to-INT ratio and 3,136 passing yards.

20 TDs? not enough.