BJ won that fight!!!!!!!

killerofchicken wrote:

timthebim wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

dana white says he believes BJ won the first 2... not that white is the best judge but i just thought that was interesting... that was a good decision

I agree with Dana that BJ won the 1st 2. Now you can argue if Fitch deserved a 10-8 or 10-9 round for the 3rd.

bj didnt do anything to keep it a 10-9 though

Yeah but in my opinion to get a 10-8 u have to be dominating(which Fitch was), hurt your opponent, and be damn near close to finishing your opponent off. I guess In my opinion Fitch wasnt close to finishing BJ and I dont think BJ was ever seriously hurt. Like I said I guess I can see a 10-8 but I really felt it was just a dominating 10-9 round.

what did fitch do in the first 2 rounds bobbit?

Apparently he got outclassed

Outclassed no, but beaten in the rounds yes.

timthebim wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

timthebim wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

dana white says he believes BJ won the first 2... not that white is the best judge but i just thought that was interesting... that was a good decision

I agree with Dana that BJ won the 1st 2. Now you can argue if Fitch deserved a 10-8 or 10-9 round for the 3rd.

bj didnt do anything to keep it a 10-9 though

Yeah but in my opinion to get a 10-8 u have to be dominating(which Fitch was), hurt your opponent, and be damn near close to finishing your opponent off. I guess In my opinion Fitch wasnt close to finishing BJ and I dont think BJ was ever seriously hurt. Like I said I guess I can see a 10-8 but I really felt it was just a dominating 10-9 round.

You can't just have your own opinion about how a fight is supposed to be scored. They have rules that lay it out for you. All that's required for a 10-8 is to be overwhelmingly dominant, which Fitch obviously was.

IMO this fight was a draw. BJ won the first, the second was even and Fitch owned BJ in the 3rd. I can understand agruements for both guys winning but imo it was a draw. Of course in my drunken fuck the BJ haters mode I was in that night made me think BJ should have won 2 rounds to 1. But watching the next day sober as I always do I saw it as BJ won the first, the second was even, and Fitch obviously won the 3rd. It was a draw

Let me say this though it was a draw in the sport of mma but if I look at it like a real fight I would say Fitch beat BJs ass cause it was basically a close grappling match that BJ was winning until Fitch trapped him up against the cage and beat him up.

I had Fitch winning, sorry had to say it.

chorky777 wrote:

timthebim wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

timthebim wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

dana white says he believes BJ won the first 2... not that white is the best judge but i just thought that was interesting... that was a good decision

I agree with Dana that BJ won the 1st 2. Now you can argue if Fitch deserved a 10-8 or 10-9 round for the 3rd.

bj didnt do anything to keep it a 10-9 though

Yeah but in my opinion to get a 10-8 u have to be dominating(which Fitch was), hurt your opponent, and be damn near close to finishing your opponent off. I guess In my opinion Fitch wasnt close to finishing BJ and I dont think BJ was ever seriously hurt. Like I said I guess I can see a 10-8 but I really felt it was just a dominating 10-9 round.

You can't just have your own opinion about how a fight is supposed to be scored. They have rules that lay it out for you. All that's required for a 10-8 is to be overwhelmingly dominant, which Fitch obviously was.

I was just talking about the way I scored the fight. Really doesnt mean much but thats what this board is for right Chork?

Just watched Penn-Fitch on TV. Rd1:10-9 BJ; Rd2: 10-10; Rd3: 10-9 Fitch. Draw. No way round 3 was a 10-8. Round 2 could really go either way

Ariel Helwani

killerofchicken wrote:

Just watched Penn-Fitch on TV. Rd1:10-9 BJ; Rd2: 10-10; Rd3: 10-9 Fitch. Draw. No way round 3 was a 10-8. Round 2 could really go either way

Ariel Helwani

I pretty much agree with this.

Quote :

"Finally watched the fight back myself. first rnd draw and I won rnd 2 and 3. I will prove myself if I must. But I know I won that fight. Much respect to BJ. He is the legend I thought he was. I think that was the best BJ ANY of us have ever seen."

jon fitch

i think fitch is delusional as well

killerofchicken wrote:

i think fitch is delusional as well

What the hell does he know he probably normally falls asleep watching replays of his fights lol.

timthebim wrote:

killerofchicken wrote:

i think fitch is delusional as well

What the hell does he know he probably normally falls asleep watching replays of his fights lol.

Super late to this party

The fight could be scored 3 ways without much arguing, just one of those fights.

I thought BJ took the first 2 rds, maybe a 10-10 2nd rd, then Fitch dominated the 3rd, but 10-8? I've seen more dominant rds not scored 10-8 is all I can say.

BJ and Fitch are both the 2nd best WW in the World.

Does anyone know if Brock/Mir II's 1st Rd was scored 10-8?

LA wrote:

Super late to this party

The fight could be scored 3 ways without much arguing, just one of those fights.

I thought BJ took the first 2 rds, maybe a 10-10 2nd rd, then Fitch dominated the 3rd, but 10-8? I've seen more dominant rds not scored 10-8 is all I can say.

BJ and Fitch are both the 2nd best WW in the World.

Does anyone know if Brock/Mir II's 1st Rd was scored 10-8?

I dont think it was. So LA u think BJ won 29-28 also?

Reason I ask, is because that rd was more dominant

Hard to be objective, but in a rd by rd basis, I think BJ won the first 2, or the 2nd was 10-10, and Fitch only won a 10-9 3rd.

LA wrote:

Reason I ask, is because that rd was more dominant

Hard to be objective, but in a rd by rd basis, I think BJ won the first 2, or the 2nd was 10-10, and Fitch only won a 10-9 3rd.

Me 2. I had BJ 10-9 in the 1st 2 rounds and Fitch 10-9 in the third. I thought BJ won the fight.

timthebim wrote:

LA wrote:

Reason I ask, is because that rd was more dominant

Hard to be objective, but in a rd by rd basis, I think BJ won the first 2, or the 2nd was 10-10, and Fitch only won a 10-9 3rd.

Me 2. I had BJ 10-9 in the 1st 2 rounds and Fitch 10-9 in the third. I thought BJ won the fight.

Yeah, I know you guys try to be objective. But it is difficult when one of your favorite guys is fighting.

OU wrote:

timthebim wrote:

LA wrote:

Reason I ask, is because that rd was more dominant

Hard to be objective, but in a rd by rd basis, I think BJ won the first 2, or the 2nd was 10-10, and Fitch only won a 10-9 3rd.

Me 2. I had BJ 10-9 in the 1st 2 rounds and Fitch 10-9 in the third. I thought BJ won the fight.

Yeah, I know you guys try to be objective. But it is difficult when one of your favorite guys is fighting.

I agree it is hard but I seriously thought BJ won the 1st 2 rounds and Fitch won the 3rd 10-9.

I honestly would have been happy for either guy if they won and disappointed for the guy who lost. Despite the fact that I defend Fitch all the time, I'm not really a "fan" of either guy but I also don't have any problems with them.

Thing I came out of this fight with, was thinking BJ and Fitch are a cut above the rest of the WWs, and GSP is on another planet.

LA wrote:

Thing I came out of this fight with, was thinking BJ and Fitch are a cut above the rest of the WWs, and GSP is on another planet.

Cant disagree with this at all. Even though I hate GSP!!!!!

not that it matters or anything but how do you guys think Frankie Edgar would fare against Fitch now that we saw BJ almost beat Fitch? i know it would never happen but just a thought lol

killerofchicken wrote:

not that it matters or anything but how do you guys think Frankie Edgar would fare against Fitch now that we saw BJ almost beat Fitch? i know it would never happen but just a thought lol

I think Fitch would own Frankie although u are right it will never happen lol.