Was TUF 10 that bad?

Good enough to beat Randy, Mir, Carwin and Herring

LA wrote:

Or you guys have to come to grips with a guy losing to two other HWs that would probably beat all but 2 others in the World, isn't that big a deal, also happen to be the 2 hardest hitting fighters in MMA. Capt. believed in Rogers he shouldn't say shit.

But I can admit that when Rogers get's tossed around the ring I need to reevaluate my thoughts on the guy.

And Brock has been bitch slapped 2 fights in a row.

LA wrote:

Good enough to beat Randy, Mir, Carwin and Herring

1)he also lost to Mir.

2)Carwin beat himself, dude gassed in 3 minutes. In a title fight. That's pathetic.

3)Randy was 45

4)Who knows where Herring is.

captain organic wrote:

timthebim wrote:

captain organic wrote:

timthebim wrote:

I knew about Roy also since then but to humor me gimmie his biggest name win??? His claim to fame is pretty much a close loss to AA. I love Big Country but he isnt beating Brock. Cain beat him but that doesnt mean every top 15 or 20 guy will.

But Cain did not just beat him, he destroyed him. Carwin should have too. Nothing that Brock did made Carwin gas in 3 minutes time.

U guys really have to come to grips with Brock not being as good as he was hyped to be.

He isnt a good as he was hyped u r right but he isnt as bad as u would like to think either.

how bad do I thin he is? I'll admit I think people ranking brock at #2 is totally ridiculous. But I still see him in the top 10.

Fact is, he has just 7 fights, it's hard know how good he is.

If u think Mir has a shot to beat him then u dont think he is nearly as good as he is. I agree with u that he shouldnt be number 2 after his last couple of fights though. He is still a top 5 fighter though. As much as he gets blasted about the Carwin fight he still beat a guy who hadnt been beaten yet and who I think we all agree was a very dangerous opponent for him.

captain organic wrote:

LA wrote:

Or you guys have to come to grips with a guy losing to two other HWs that would probably beat all but 2 others in the World, isn't that big a deal, also happen to be the 2 hardest hitting fighters in MMA. Capt. believed in Rogers he shouldn't say shit.

But I can admit that when Rogers get's tossed around the ring I need to reevaluate my thoughts on the guy.

And Brock has been bitch slapped 2 fights in a row.

Yeah but he won one of those fights, Nog was beaten down many times to comeback and win.....

captain organic wrote:

LA wrote:

Good enough to beat Randy, Mir, Carwin and Herring

1)he also lost to Mir.

2)Carwin beat himself, dude gassed in 3 minutes. In a title fight. That's pathetic.

Fedor beat himself against Werdum, basically put himself in a triangle/armbar

That Mir fight was a proven fluke, Mir was destroyed for all but 2 seconds of their fights, plus that was Brock's 2nd fight in MMA, very very green..

LA wrote:

captain organic wrote:

LA wrote:

Good enough to beat Randy, Mir, Carwin and Herring

1)he also lost to Mir.

2)Carwin beat himself, dude gassed in 3 minutes. In a title fight. That's pathetic.

Fedor beat himself against Werdum, basically put himself in a triangle/armbar

That Mir fight was a proven fluke, Mir was destroyed for all but 2 seconds of their fights, plus that was Brock's 2nd fight in MMA, very very green..

U havent heard Brock cant get better he is just muscles LOL....

LA wrote:

captain organic wrote:

LA wrote:

Good enough to beat Randy, Mir, Carwin and Herring

1)he also lost to Mir.

2)Carwin beat himself, dude gassed in 3 minutes. In a title fight. That's pathetic.

Fedor beat himself against Werdum, basically put himself in a triangle/armbar

That Mir fight was a proven fluke, Mir was destroyed for all but 2 seconds of their fights, plus that was Brock's 2nd fight in MMA, very very green..

Werdum is too good of a BJJ practioner to make that statement.

timthebim wrote:

LA wrote:

captain organic wrote:

LA wrote:

Good enough to beat Randy, Mir, Carwin and Herring

1)he also lost to Mir.

2)Carwin beat himself, dude gassed in 3 minutes. In a title fight. That's pathetic.

Fedor beat himself against Werdum, basically put himself in a triangle/armbar

That Mir fight was a proven fluke, Mir was destroyed for all but 2 seconds of their fights, plus that was Brock's 2nd fight in MMA, very very green..

U havent heard Brock cant get better he is just muscles LOL....

yeah cause he looked so much better in recent fights.

No, not really, it was sloppy as hell,