New Top 10 HW

What is you're new top 10 HW list look like?

Mine:

1. Fedor
2. Lesnar
3. Big Nog
4. Mir
5. Barnett
6. Randy
7. Rogers
8. Shane
9. Cain
10. Overeem

01. Fedor
02. Lesnar
03. Mir
04. Big Nog
05. Barnett
06. Shane
07. Cain
08. Randy
09. Rogers
10. Overeem

Mir beat Nog injured or not. Mir stays ahead of him unless either Nog beats Mir or Lesnar or Mir losses to someone ranked lower.

1. Fedor
2. Big Nog
3. Barnett
4. Lesnar
5. Shane
6. Cain
7. Randy
8. Rogers
9. Werdum
10. Overeem

Mir isn't top ten guys, sorry.

He's beaten Lesnar and Nog in 2 of his last 3 fights yet he's still not top 10?

That NOG wins clearly doesn't count as that NOG could have been KO'd by Forrest Griffin. Lesnar dominated Mir in 99% of all their fight time apart from the time the big idiot oaf was warned to stop hitting the back of his head and didn't listen, which cost him the fight since he then left his leg right there for Mir to snap it off.

Outside of a green Lesnar with no fight experience who absolutely was not top ten at the time, and a half dead NOG who had no business even fighting, what has he done? get smashed by Vera? Ok gotcha.

Mir the most over valued fighter in MMA history.




And people have the balls to claim the UFC HW division is more legit than Fedor these days?

I didn't read Wolfy's post at first and was about to type basically the same thing

1- Fedor



2- Brock
3- Nog
4- Mir
5- Barnett
6- Couture
7- Carwin
8- Rogers
9- Overeem
10- Arlovski

1. Fedor
2. Lesnar
3. Nogueira
4. Barnett
5. Mir
6. Couture
7. Carwin
8. Rogers
9. Arlovski
10. Werdum

Surprised Mir hasn't dropped farther on these lists when it's clear he is a paper tiger at this point.

Mir beat Nog fair and square. You can't use injury or sickness as an excuse. If you enter the cage then bad luck. If Nog wasn't fit he should've posponed the fight.

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Surprised Mir hasn't dropped farther on these lists when it's clear he is a paper tiger at this point.

I think Mir sucks but he does have wins against Lesnar and Nog, even though Nog was in no condition to fight.

It's only a matter of time before he drops off everyone's list though. Probably after his next fight if he's serious about standing with Kongo.

I think GG cracks the top ten with his win. His losses against Carwin and Randy were against quality opponents.

1 Fedor
2 chestnar
3 Nog
4 Barnett
5 Randy
6 Carwin
7 Overeem
8 Werdum
9 Cain
10 Rodgers

Only changes I would make is flip Randy and Nog from my last rankings.

freakzilla316ftw wrote:

Mir beat Nog fair and square. You can't use injury or sickness as an excuse. If you enter the cage then bad luck. If Nog wasn't fit he should've posponed the fight.

It's not an excuse. It's like the Lions beating the Steelers or something in week 16 when all their starters are rested for the playoffs when the Lions are simply trying to earn a win. Not the same.

It doesn't take away Nog's loss, but it does reflect on Mir's win. "fair and square wins" and data to use toward rankings are not the same. If Dave Menne KO'd Anderson Silva because he had H1N1 and a broken arm, that win wouldn't count that much either.

Ninja\Rua/Fan wrote:

What is you're new top 10 HW list look like?

Mine:

1. Fedor
2. Lesnar
3. Big Nog
4. Mir
5. Barnett
6. Randy
7. Rogers
8. Shane
9. Cain
10. Overeem

Not a bad list mine is like this.....
1.Fedor
2.Brock
3.Barnett
4.Nog
5.Rogers
6.Mir
7.Carwin
8.Randy
9.Cain
10.Gabe Gonzaga