New P4P lists!

YEP! Im opening up another one after having watched some guys that were on the brink of cracking into my top 10 p4p and now I also have Fedor back up at #1.

1. Fedor
2. Anderson Silva
3. GSP!
4. Lyoto Machida
5. BJ Penn
6. Mike Brown
7. Gegard Mousasi
8. Shogun
9. Dan Henderson
10. Jake Shields

Honorable Mentions: Urijah Faber, Mike Swick, and Vitor Belfort.

shogun would beat gegard.

I dunno about that Golb.

it'd be a close fight IMO. As of right now, i think Shogun would probably have the slight advantage but idk...very close fight.

I already created a thread about Mousasi vs. Machida (which got turned into a Machida/Shogun vs. Mousasi if you want to check that out).

1. Fedor
2. Spider
3. GSP
4. Penn
5. Machida
6. Brown
7. Shogun
8. Mousasi
9. Faber
10. Bowles

I really can't pick between Fedor and Spider at #1 so I just put Fedor first b/c i like him better.

Rashad and Belfort just outside

1. Fedor
2. Anderson
3. GSP
4a&b. Machida/Shogun
6. Mousasi
7. Penn
8. MTB
9. Faber
10. Bowles

Consideration... Hendo, Fitch, Aoki, Marquardt, Evans, Torres, Lesnar, Sandro, Nog


Just shows you how far ahead of the rest of the HW world Fedor really is...

Consideration to Lesnar? A man who only wins because he is a big meathead?

1. Spider
2. Fedor
3. GSP
4. Penn
5. Machida
6. Brown
7. Brock
8. Rampage
9. Shields
10. Rashad

Wolfgangsta wrote:

Consideration to Lesnar? A man who only wins because he is a big meathead?

Ahhhh, but the meathead wins nonetheless and does hold the UFC HW belt.

1 Fedor
2 Silva
3 GSP
4 Penn
5 Shogun
6 Mousasi
8 Machida
9 Brown
10 Hendo

Tim Sylvia was p4p then too? That Peter Jackson - Tolkien troll that Haye beat for the title, p4p too?

Sadly, I remember after doubling Arlovski up seeing Sylvia at the bottom or on honorable mention lists for P4P. Don't say it didn't happen, cuz you know it did...lol.

1. Shogun
2. Gegard
3. Spider
4. Diego Sanchez
5. Torres
6. Rampage
7. Fedor
8. Lesnar
9. GSP
10. Machida

Jeeezus GolbeZ, that is an ugly list. Good to see you have a sense of humor today...

Golbez is like that guy who ranks McNabb over Rothlisberger. No ryhme or reason to his madness.

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

Jeeezus GolbeZ, that is an ugly list. Good to see you have a sense of humor today...

well I was more trying to make fun of GDP's list..

lol... I didn't think GDP's list was "that" off base. But your's was Fleaveresque...

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

lol... I didn't think GDP's list was "that" off base. But your's was Fleaveresque...

really? like how he just decided for the hell of it to skip 7 and move Machida to 8.. or like how gegard is ranked above machida coming off a fight that if Soko took some viagra before the fight could have won it.. like I have already said, soko won the first round .. and putting shogun above machida is fine, but I wouldnt because I saw the fight closer than most and I also think Lyoto wins the rematch soo

he should just take machida off his list, I know he wants to.

Quote :

1 Fedor
2 Silva
3 GSP
4 Penn
5 Shogun
6 Mousasi
8 Machida
9 Brown
10 Hendo

1. Fedor
2. Anderson
3. GSP
4. Penn
5. MTB
6. Shogun
7. Machida
8. Gegard
9. Bowles
10. Sheilds

Are Tims and GolbeZs lists for real?

Ninja\Rua/Fan wrote:

Are Tims and GolbeZs lists for real?

no mine wasn't

GolbeZ wrote:

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

lol... I didn't think GDP's list was "that" off base. But your's was Fleaveresque...

really? like how he just decided for the hell of it to skip 7 and move Machida to 8.. or like how gegard is ranked above machida coming off a fight that if Soko took some viagra before the fight could have won it.. like I have already said, soko won the first round .. and putting shogun above machida isnt a bad thing, but I wouldnt because I saw the fight closer than most and I also think Lyoto wins the rematch soo

he should just take machida off his list, I know he wants to.

Quote :

1 Fedor
2 Silva
3 GSP
4 Penn
5 Shogun
6 Mousasi
8 Machida
9 Brown
10 Hendo

LOL... Missed the 7 being gone, nice catch. I'm not digging on anyone having their liberties with the LHW division as long as they realize that it's currently a 4 man show. As far as Mousasi/Soko is concerned, we have seen too much of Mousasi in the last two years to think he's not legit. And we all know that Soko is a fighter of what if's... He's just a ton of unrealized potential.

Now you have me wondering who GDP has at 7... Bowles? Or was his intent to not get laughed at for having Brock there?

Ninja\Rua/Fan wrote:

Are Tims and GolbeZs lists for real?

Tim's 7-10 are classic.

LikesToFightGuy wrote:

Ninja\Rua/Fan wrote:

Are Tims and GolbeZs lists for real?

Tim's 7-10 are classic.

Ya, his list is alright except Lesnar, Rampage, Rashad really don't belong IMO.

Lesnar biggest advantage is his size and with out that I don't think he would be that dominant. So that disqualifies him from being one of the P4P best.

Rampage isn't even a fighter anymore.

Rashad could make sense, but Shogun would have to be in front of him. Rashad had absolutely nothing for Machida while Shogun arguably beat him.

Machida is no seven in my eyes.